Rohit Sharma could keep up the good form he showed in the ODI World Cup in the T20 World Cup. He already knows what he wants. Who is to say that he doesn’t kick up the 135-plus strike rate during the powerplays in ODIs and keep going even harder after the sixth over in T20s, not taking many wickets because he knows there is more work to come?

Virat Kohli could face the spin bowlers in the middle overs if he makes up his mind. He can even start the innings, making the other team bowl spin in the powerplay. He hits them, though, because India has to deal with less spin in the middle overs because of field restrictions.

Anything can happen in T20 cricket because the weather is so hard to predict. But on this day, January 8, about five months before the T20 World Cup, India is clearly doing the same thing over and over again in the hopes of getting different results.

The last four T20 World Cups have all been the same. India’s top order was caught playing first in a game, which was not smart, and they were out of the game. There must be good reasons to keep the same team for the Afghanistan T20I series, unless they want to win every toss and be in charge of the chase. This pretty much means that Rohit and Kohli will go to the World Cup now, even though they haven’t played in a T20 international since the 2022 World Cup.

It’s been since 2018 that Rohit hasn’t hit 140 or more runs in a T20 match. Since he hasn’t hit a ball in a while, his IPL team has already replaced him as leader.

Kohli faced 124 balls with spin in the middle overs of the IPL last year, and his strike rate was only 110. He only tried 32 times to hit an edge. In the middle overs, Suryakumar Yadav met 148 balls with spin and only tried to hit a four off of 59 of them. In the middle overs of the IPL, a boundary try was made every 3.43 balls of spin. This is more often than Kohli’s rate of every 3.88 balls. Kohli’s main job will be in these middle overs if he bats at No. 3.

All of these points are very clear and easy to understand. The people who choose the players and run the team have more advanced measures that will tell them that an XI is too small for two batters like that. Maybe even one. The people making the decisions are smart former cricket players who are not careless. So, since there wasn’t a press meeting after the choice, we need to try to think of good reasons.

Hardik Pandya is hurt. When he’s healthy and available, things don’t always go as planned. Suryakumar led the team in the Australia T20Is in late November of last year while he was away, but he is also hurt. It looks like the leader of this team for the Afghanistan series was chosen before the best 15 players were even thought about. It looks like they thought the team needed a leader and thought Rohit’s play and attitude in ODIs were good signs.

Most likely, it became even more unpopular and risky when they brought Rohit back but not Kohli. This would have been a bad choice anyway, but how do you bring back one and leave out the other? We saw that problem coming as soon as Rahul Dravid agreed to stay on as a guide for another year.

After a month, the team leaders have decided to bring back both Rohit and Kohli, even though they know everything. This means that Tilak Varma, Shreyas Iyer, and Rinku Singh probably won’t be able to play. For that matter, Shubman Gill had a great IPL 2023 season that showed he was ready to play T20 cricket. These are the players who give the team more order. They can hit left-handed, spin, or “finish them off.” Players that the bosses put a lot of faith in between the two World Cups. Players who showed what they could do.

Kohli seems to have read the room, which is the only good thing about this. In the middle overs of the IPL 2022, he hit one out of every eight balls with spin. His strike rate was 105. That goal has definitely gotten better. Kohli is also being asked to play better in this series against Afghanistan and the IPL 2024, since he could have walked right back into the T20 World Cup team without playing any games first. It’s likely the same for Rohit.

After that, they could still be left out, either one or both, if their game doesn’t look good enough for T20. A part of them probably won’t come back because it’s the right thing to do. that they might have to work hard to get their spots.

These two are the best athletes and batters in the world. They can do anything they set their minds to if they really want to. It might be easier for Rohit than for Kohli, whose game is better suited to this format than to the other two. Kohli is batting better than he ever has in these three forms. But at this point, all of that is more hope than facts-based belief.